Thread: Aamir or Shahrukh: who is better?

I know SRK is a good actor no doubt in that but still in case of hit film we all know how it possible for famous star every movie are big budget lots of promotion,advertisement using print media and electronic media very well his movie gets most of the famous distributor and his star status it all helps to hit his movie .I watch few recent movie of SRK his acting is good but still i don't like his recent movie because nothing special in his few latest movie(typical masala movie) .

Originally Posted by itsmemad

Man, SRK isn't a cheap... His each movie is a block-buster... Just the kind of hits those legends gave during their respective careers...

ya few of his movies are guuud but sorry i cant except him as an guuud actor......i also love his KKHH and KHNH but not for his acting but for the direction......

and lets c aamirs latest movies.
ghajini,rdb,dch...not masala movies!!!
ryt!!

Originally Posted by ag_prasun

and lets c aamirs latest movies.
ghajini,rdb,dch...not masala movies!!!
ryt!!

no we are not talking bout movies we are talking bout acting.......aamirs acting in these 3 movies is koool but to rate the movie i never vote for ghajini this movie is not so guud.........

one more thing i just love SRKs Swadesh and chalte chalte......

Originally Posted by amitkool21

i would say that aamir is definately in a league of his own. he is awesome with all the diff types of roles he has played (rangeela, DCH, Andaz apna apna, lagaan, JJWS, sarfarosh..........the list goes on). but i would surely like to see a flick with both of em starring in it. A

Originally Posted by powerdoc

Don't think both of them together in a film is going to happen.

Rajkumar Shantoshi did plan a movie having Aaamir and SRK in lead roles a decade back after the success of Andaz Apna Apna.It was tentively titled 'Raks'.Raks means jealousy.But somehow the project never took off.

both actors are as good as each other in their own ways, yes Aamir Khan is always in a very different and unique role which is why many people look forward to his films. But Shahrukh also have a big fan following because of his acting as well which makes him as popular!

@ amitguy - you cant call SRK cheap guy, just because your favourite is Aamir, talk about being biased!

If SRK's acting isn't good or he isn't good, he wouldn't be this famous or popular, and in fact he is very popular worldwide especially with the girls!

SRK's acting is good, just that it looks monotonous when he's doing the same roles again & again.
What happened to the SRK of Darr & Baazigar ?

Originally Posted by Preeti_20

@ amitguy - you cant call SRK cheap guy, just because your favourite is Aamir, talk about being biased!

If SRK's acting isn't good or he isn't good, he wouldn't be this famous or popular, and in fact he is very popular worldwide especially with the girls!

Aamir is not my favourite one dear........nd we'r talkin bout acting not looks...most of the people just goes to theatre just for 2 nd a half Hrs of entertainment they wont observe the acting part that what he did wrong and which is the best part of his acting.......nd he is very famous in abroad coz he alwayz plays roles of that kind which NRI people just loves.........nd being famous is not that great task in industry even Mallika Sherawat also famous.......

My Vote goes to Aamir Khan, for the very fact.
whatever he does, he does it with perfection

as an actor i ll say aamir,but shahrukhs made himself more popular(he's got the talent for that)

aamir and shahrukh cannot be compared like this ... they are experts in their own places ... both have their own specialities ...

yea saurav......both r good at their own work.....n ve got skills....!!!

i m asking here y did we forget the 3rd major khan here......Salman.....hez carved a niche for himself in the industry as well......

Originally Posted by aashaka_gandhi

yea saurav......both r good at their own work.....n ve got skills....!!!

i m asking here y did we forget the 3rd major khan here......Salman.....hez carved a niche for himself in the industry as well......

he only just carved him from outside........but for acting he ll get -ve points frm my side.......

salman has definitely carved a niche for himself.he is now the most prolific alcoholic-abusive-drunk driver-animal hunter-girl chaser in bollywood !!

tht was a sad one......

sad, but true!

Originally Posted by aashaka_gandhi

yea saurav......both r good at their own work.....n ve got skills....!!!

i m asking here y did we forget the 3rd major khan here......Salman.....hez carved a niche for himself in the industry as well......

i admire salman's physique and his huge fan following ... but it comes to acting and serious roles with some class i would say salman is a good for nothing ... i know many ppl will come up with the "tere naam" against my comment but that movie was an exception ... acting is not like what he does in movies like hello brother,maine pyar kyun kiya,god tussi gr8 ho etc ....

Salman's acting & selection of roles deteriorated proportionately to improvement in his body...

What he does in his personal life doesn't really concern me...

well for tht even SRK's soo many movies r flops, aamir's movies were flop, akki's chandnichowk a super flop......every actor makes a mistake in selecting roles......but tht does not mean hez bad at it...!!! neva therless...i vent seen tere naam....but one of salmans movie tht was too good was ''GARV''

Salman is a good actor but last few year he is just neglecting the acting in movie.Just what aashaka said in Tere Naam climax scene he acted superbly 10 min without any word he express his feelings only by expression.SRK's movie last time flop almost 3 years ago if he will keep doing such type of movie(Om Santi Om,Rab Ne Bana de Jodi) then it's very rear chance to flop that in near future.But if he try something realistic or epic movie or if he try to do some others new directors movie(other than Johar,Akhtar,Adi) then may be his movie can also be flop also.

srk is very good at making movies with almost no story in it superhit ... his expressions are gr8 ... he adds life to every dialog , every scene ... so a srk movie being superflop is really rare ... on the other part ... i think most of u here like swades very much and it was really a gr8 movie .... but it was not a hit ...

okie so i aint alone....whoz a SRK fan......

Of course Aamir, Each time Aamir Khan brings something new to the people, he don't stick to just one subject. Just checkout his movie list and you will know that in every film he has brought something new & Interesting. He works with dedications and though he never comes to awards may be due to some issue was happened. But he always respects his fans.

in short ...

aamir is a genious

shah rukh is a charm

salman is a good for nothing

well correction..
he doesnt come to IDIAN awards..that snob!!
talk abt the oscars and hes running around the jury...
nowadays his favorite work,that he des without fail and sincerely is criticise and try to humiliate srk!!