India Broadband Forum

aashaka_gandhi · 08-14-09, 01:42 PM

coz the movie is gng nowhr....damn first half only i was sick of it......as in WTH is gng on??????

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pri_dm

It got 4 in TOI

jus coz its a vishal bhardwaj movie.....

08-14-09, 01:47 PM

Ohhho.. What do you mean by WTH is going on...
What exactly you didn't like.. Acting, Violence, Humour, Story, Direction or all together?

08-14-09, 01:48 PM

Ohhho.. What do you mean by WTH is going on...
What exactly you didn't like.. Acting, Violence, Humour, Story, Direction or all together?

08-14-09, 01:50 PM

According to TOI - More importantly, Kaminey is the first film which also credits its viewers with some intelligence. It demands your unbridled attention from the word GO and allows you to sit back only at your own peril. For if you aren't attentive and intelligent to figure some things out yourself, specially in the first half hour, you might be missing the twists in this sassy tale of twin brothers who end up hating and loving each other, all in a frenetic 24-hour time span. Of course, director Vishal Bhardwaj does tell it all gradually, but he presumes you'll solve the jigsaw without much of spoon feeding. And therein lies the power of Kaminey. It teases you with its smartness and constantly challenges you to keep pace with the breathless tenor of the drama that unfolds through fast cuts, dizzy hand-held camera angles and a dark, brooding ambience. Watching Kaminey is like sitting on the edge of a volcano which can explode any time. And explode it does!

08-14-09, 01:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pri_dm

According to TOI - More importantly, Kaminey is the first film which also credits its viewers with some intelligence. It demands your unbridled attention from the word GO and allows you to sit back only at your own peril. For if you aren't attentive and intelligent to figure some things out yourself, specially in the first half hour, you might be missing the twists in this sassy tale of twin brothers who end up hating and loving each other, all in a frenetic 24-hour time span. Of course, director Vishal Bhardwaj does tell it all gradually, but he presumes you'll solve the jigsaw without much of spoon feeding. And therein lies the power of Kaminey. It teases you with its smartness and constantly challenges you to keep pace with the breathless tenor of the drama that unfolds through fast cuts, dizzy hand-held camera angles and a dark, brooding ambience. Watching Kaminey is like sitting on the edge of a volcano which can explode any time. And explode it does!

Holla! What an explanation, What do you think guys, how much Vishal paid to TOE??

Rameshjeee · 08-14-09, 01:53 PM

I have been hearing good reviews for the movie. I am very very eager to watch the movie. I just cannot wait for tomorrow evening. I know that I will like the movie. I have been waiting for this movie for quite some time.

08-14-09, 01:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rameshjeee

I have been hearing good reviews for the movie. I am very very eager to watch the movie. I just cannot wait for tomorrow evening. I know that I will like the movie. I have been waiting for this movie for quite some time.

Remember Ghazini??

You waited for that movie for ages and then what happened

08-14-09, 01:57 PM

I will wait till few more of my frens comment on it till now only 5 of my frens have seen the movie and they liked it. Anyways sunday i need to go and meet my frens in whitefield will watch it in whitefiled fame cinemas.

Rameshjeee · 08-14-09, 01:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragon

Remember Ghazini??

You waited for that movie for ages and then what happened

I had already seen the tamil version. So the hindi version didn't have much impact on me.

aashaka_gandhi · 08-14-09, 02:03 PM

well we saw the movie with all de seriousness ...but i definately didnt like the whole movie over all......

i still wonder wht he is trying to portray .....more than this i thght ishqiya his forthcoming movie seeems to be more better.....

as such kaminey trailers neva impressed me....

08-14-09, 02:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragon

Holla! What an explanation, What do you think guys, how much Vishal paid to TOE??

Well above explanation of direction by TOI really made me think that he(Vishal) did inspired by Quentin Tarantino and Guy Ritchie... I'm surely gonna watch this movie..

@aaka
Did you watched any of quentin tarantino or guy ritchie movie?

08-14-09, 05:28 PM

Just 1/5 ?

Even Vishal wouldn't have expected that.

Well,I can't believe such a

reviews by AG.

itsmemad · 08-15-09, 06:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by aashaka_gandhi

jus coz its a vishal bhardwaj movie.....

Who is he?

08-15-09, 02:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by itsmemad

Who is he?

Lol, yes who is he?

mickey · 08-15-09, 02:53 PM

kaifi lagi yeh film???

a good to fee in hall or chote parde pe hi dekhna chahiye/??

Rameshjeee · 08-16-09, 11:04 AM

I never felt that I was watching a movie. It was so real. I really enjoyed the movie.

Everything was perfect in the movie: The characters, the story, the screenplay & the dialogue. Not a single scene in the movie is wasted. On a whole, Kaminey is well made movie.

to Vishal Bharadwaj's Kaminey.

The story is about is 2 brothers Guddu & Charlie (Shahid Kapoor), who are twins.Charlie has a dream of making big in to the betting (Horse Racing) world. He dreams of having his own betting counter. One night in a series of incidents he get hold of a Guitar case containing Cocaine worth 10 crores. Tasi (Don) instructs 2 cops to get get back the guitar case from Charlie. The 2 cops (corrupted) are after Charlie. Charlie tells Mikhail (Chandan Roy) about the cocaine he has. Mikhail is Charlie's best friend. He loves Mikhail more than his brother. Mikhail is one of three Bengali brothers for whom Charlie works.

Then we have Guddu, who works for a NGO. Sweety (Pryanka) tells him one day that she is pregnant. She also tells him that she is the sister of Bope Bhau (Amol Guple). Bope Bhau wants to become big in to politics. So Guddu & Sweety both decide to marry. Bope Bhau dosent; like this relation as Guddu is non-Maharashtrian. So he sends his guys to get Sweety. When the marriage is happening (its almost over), Bope Bhau men arrive there & start hitting Guddu. Guddu & Sweety are on the run.

Now both these incidents: Guddu & Sweey on the run & Charlie on the run happens on the same night.Bhope Bahu wants Guddu. The 2 cops & Tashi wants Charlie. Guddu gets caught by the police mistaking him as Charlie & Bope Bahu goes to Chalie's den mistaking him as Guddu.

INTERVAL - Have a Break

At Charlie's den, Bope's men kill Mikahil in front of Charlie. Both the cops & Bope comes to know that Charlie & Guddu are twins & decide to exchange Guddu & Charlie. Charlie manages to escape from those 2 cops. He contacts Tashi & makes a deal with him for the guitar case for 10 crores. On the other side Guddu make a deal with Bope for the guitar case to get Sweety.

Then we have an interesting climax. All the characters are present in the climax: Guddu, Sweety, Charlie, Corrupted Cop, Tashi, Bhope & the 2 Benagali Brothers.

Some of my favorite scenes:
Priyanka telling to Guddu about her pregnancy.
The 2 cops interrogating Guddu by asking him to sing his statement.

My Review: 4.5/5
I would surely have Kaminey DVD in my collection.

08-16-09, 01:29 PM

Nice Review Jee

Completely opposite to what Aaka said.

Now I am in two minds,whether to watch this movie or not.

08-16-09, 03:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sid

Nice Review Jee

Completely opposite to what Aaka said.

Now I am in two minds,whether to watch this movie or not.

Let me help you.. Watch it

aashaka_gandhi · 08-17-09, 04:28 PM

yea u to always like to say opposite of whteva i say.....neva mind....

i wud say ur choice.....

atleast the ppl i told no ....went n saw the movie n found it to be crappy movie....

Rameshjeee · 08-17-09, 05:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by aashaka_gandhi

yea u to always like to say opposite of whteva i say.....neva mind....

i wud say ur choice.....

atleast the ppl i told no ....went n saw the movie n found it to be crappy movie....

What to do, no two people are same....

08-16-09, 11:04 AM	#36
Rameshjeee Aadhavan is Coming Join Date: Aug 2008 Location: Leaving Chennai Age: 26 Posts: 3,075 Rep Power: 10	Kaminey Review - 4.5/5 I never felt that I was watching a movie. It was so real. I really enjoyed the movie. Everything was perfect in the movie: The characters, the story, the screenplay & the dialogue. Not a single scene in the movie is wasted. On a whole, Kaminey is well made movie. to Vishal Bharadwaj's Kaminey. The story is about is 2 brothers Guddu & Charlie (Shahid Kapoor), who are twins.Charlie has a dream of making big in to the betting (Horse Racing) world. He dreams of having his own betting counter. One night in a series of incidents he get hold of a Guitar case containing Cocaine worth 10 crores. Tasi (Don) instructs 2 cops to get get back the guitar case from Charlie. The 2 cops (corrupted) are after Charlie. Charlie tells Mikhail (Chandan Roy) about the cocaine he has. Mikhail is Charlie's best friend. He loves Mikhail more than his brother. Mikhail is one of three Bengali brothers for whom Charlie works. Then we have Guddu, who works for a NGO. Sweety (Pryanka) tells him one day that she is pregnant. She also tells him that she is the sister of Bope Bhau (Amol Guple). Bope Bhau wants to become big in to politics. So Guddu & Sweety both decide to marry. Bope Bhau dosent; like this relation as Guddu is non-Maharashtrian. So he sends his guys to get Sweety. When the marriage is happening (its almost over), Bope Bhau men arrive there & start hitting Guddu. Guddu & Sweety are on the run. Now both these incidents: Guddu & Sweey on the run & Charlie on the run happens on the same night.Bhope Bahu wants Guddu. The 2 cops & Tashi wants Charlie. Guddu gets caught by the police mistaking him as Charlie & Bope Bahu goes to Chalie's den mistaking him as Guddu. INTERVAL - Have a Break At Charlie's den, Bope's men kill Mikahil in front of Charlie. Both the cops & Bope comes to know that Charlie & Guddu are twins & decide to exchange Guddu & Charlie. Charlie manages to escape from those 2 cops. He contacts Tashi & makes a deal with him for the guitar case for 10 crores. On the other side Guddu make a deal with Bope for the guitar case to get Sweety. Then we have an interesting climax. All the characters are present in the climax: Guddu, Sweety, Charlie, Corrupted Cop, Tashi, Bhope & the 2 Benagali Brothers. Some of my favorite scenes: Priyanka telling to Guddu about her pregnancy. The 2 cops interrogating Guddu by asking him to sing his statement. My Review: 4.5/5 I would surely have Kaminey DVD in my collection. Last edited by Rameshjeee; 08-16-09 at 12:59 PM.

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Kambakkht Ishq Movie Review	britneyjohn	Bollywood movies	1	07-12-09 11:22 AM
Kaminey	Preeti_20	Bollywood movies	3	05-13-09 06:07 PM
Review:Valkyrie (WW II Movie)	ShAdOwCoN	Hollywood movies	0	04-20-09 12:13 AM
Shahid Kapoor and Priyanka Chopra upcoming movie "KAMINEY"	danny86	Bollywood movies	4	04-01-09 02:44 PM
Review of hollywood movie recently watched	itsmemad	Hollywood movies	65	01-15-09 05:08 PM

India Broadband Forum

Movie Review: Kaminey

Movie Review: Kaminey

Similar Threads

08-14-09, 01:47 PM	#22
gothic_coder Guest Posts: n/a	Ohhho.. What do you mean by WTH is going on... What exactly you didn't like.. Acting, Violence, Humour, Story, Direction or all together?

08-14-09, 01:48 PM	#23
gothic_coder Guest Posts: n/a	Ohhho.. What do you mean by WTH is going on... What exactly you didn't like.. Acting, Violence, Humour, Story, Direction or all together?

08-14-09, 01:50 PM	#24
Pri_dm Guest Posts: n/a	According to TOI - More importantly, Kaminey is the first film which also credits its viewers with some intelligence. It demands your unbridled attention from the word GO and allows you to sit back only at your own peril. For if you aren't attentive and intelligent to figure some things out yourself, specially in the first half hour, you might be missing the twists in this sassy tale of twin brothers who end up hating and loving each other, all in a frenetic 24-hour time span. Of course, director Vishal Bhardwaj does tell it all gradually, but he presumes you'll solve the jigsaw without much of spoon feeding. And therein lies the power of Kaminey. It teases you with its smartness and constantly challenges you to keep pace with the breathless tenor of the drama that unfolds through fast cuts, dizzy hand-held camera angles and a dark, brooding ambience. Watching Kaminey is like sitting on the edge of a volcano which can explode any time. And explode it does!

08-14-09, 01:53 PM	#26
Rameshjeee Aadhavan is Coming Join Date: Aug 2008 Location: Leaving Chennai Age: 26 Posts: 3,075 Rep Power: 10	I have been hearing good reviews for the movie. I am very very eager to watch the movie. I just cannot wait for tomorrow evening. I know that I will like the movie. I have been waiting for this movie for quite some time.

08-14-09, 01:57 PM	#28
Pri_dm Guest Posts: n/a	I will wait till few more of my frens comment on it till now only 5 of my frens have seen the movie and they liked it. Anyways sunday i need to go and meet my frens in whitefield will watch it in whitefiled fame cinemas.

08-14-09, 02:03 PM	#30
aashaka_gandhi De WatEvaa SweetHeart Join Date: Nov 2008 Location: Ahmedabad Posts: 3,046 Rep Power: 8	well we saw the movie with all de seriousness ...but i definately didnt like the whole movie over all...... i still wonder wht he is trying to portray .....more than this i thght ishqiya his forthcoming movie seeems to be more better..... as such kaminey trailers neva impressed me....

08-14-09, 05:28 PM	#32
Sid Guest Posts: n/a	Just 1/5 ? Even Vishal wouldn't have expected that. Well,I can't believe such a reviews by AG.

08-15-09, 02:53 PM	#35
mickey Senior Member & Mod Join Date: Jan 2009 Location: Delhi Posts: 3,303 Blog Entries: 3 Rep Power: 8	kaifi lagi yeh film??? a good to fee in hall or chote parde pe hi dekhna chahiye/??

08-16-09, 01:29 PM	#37
Sid Guest Posts: n/a	Nice Review Jee Completely opposite to what Aaka said. Now I am in two minds,whether to watch this movie or not.

08-17-09, 04:28 PM	#39
aashaka_gandhi De WatEvaa SweetHeart Join Date: Nov 2008 Location: Ahmedabad Posts: 3,046 Rep Power: 8	yea u to always like to say opposite of whteva i say.....neva mind.... i wud say ur choice..... atleast the ppl i told no ....went n saw the movie n found it to be crappy movie....