Historical Verdict by Delhi Court Delhi court legalized the homosexuality.This is one of the historical verdict by Delhi court under the IPC 377.Although few political party and religious leader not happy with this decision and may be few part of society will also not support such decision.
So question is without support of society implementation of such law can by practically possible ?
Source:Gay sex legalised by Delhi High Court: Rediff.com news
samajwadi ki lag gayi re mamu
verdict is one thing. but social acceptance is still years away
yes I agree with you Indian society will take so many year to accept it also unless society accept them(homosexual couple) they can't spend happy life in this country.Originally Posted by panchabhut
So true. Even inter-caste marriage is still unacceptable to a
large number of Indians.
Why was this illegal in the first place?
It takes years and years for the Indian people to get with it.
job takes the child away.
Verdict is the one big step towards making the homosexuality legal. Now since it's no longer a crime (at least legally) social acceptance will definitely follow. It's just a matter of time when our own panditji utters "I Now Pronounce You Chuck and Larry".
I don't think inter-caste marriage was ever illegal. It was just socially unacceptable.
Correct me if I am wrong.
Last edited by nandini; 3rd July 2009 at 10:54 AM. Reason: Automerged Doublepost
वन्दे मातरम्
meh.. what the f... they try to copy the us in every controversial way.. even gays face opposition over there...they'l be probably killed by angry mobs over here.
DON'T beam me up, Scotty!
Copying good things from others is not a bad idea at all. It's called refinement.
We humans have become civilized by continual refinement only.
Don't you agree that?
So if the Indian policymaker realized that gays are humans too and gave them their due rights, is it really a matter to crib, no matter whether we copied the policy from US or from "YOU".
I think by "angry mobs" you mean fanatics. Well would you really like to take a bunch of fanatics into consideration while making a policy??
I hope not!!!
So just salute for the brave step that India took yesterday.
PS: please read gays as homosexuals.
वन्दे मातरम्
oops i was to make this thread .....got a msg yest noon .....but got busy teasing some frens around n forgot....nevertheless.....
I would say its a verdict which atleast finally made some one happy ...... theres nothing wrong in it......
I was reading the newspaper AM today morning n they had got some views from Hindu Pandits & Astrologers, Muslim LEaders & Christian Fathers from some churches ......n i was like whr does it harm them tht thy r opposing this.....
Infact in a way if we see....there might b some benefits too....specially in our country ....whr population is a problem.....we cannot force any individual to live a life whre he does not belong.....
Sexual Orientation is ofcourse as per an individual.....be it normal, gay, bisexual.....n so on.......
I support the decision....!
Dont count wat u lost, cherish wat u ve & plan wat to gain...coz past neva returns but future may return the lost! Think-Decide-Act!!!!
A 'refinement' in an unrefined community is a bad idea....Copying good things from others is not a bad idea at all. It's called refinement.
We humans have become civilized by continual refinement only.
Don't you agree that?
So if the Indian policymaker realized that gays are humans too and gave them their due rights, is it really a matter to crib, no matter whether we copied the policy from US or from "YOU".
I think by "angry mobs" you mean fanatics. Well would you really like to take a bunch of fanatics into consideration while making a policy??
I hope not!!!
So just salute for the brave step that India took yesterday.
PS: please read gays as homosexuals.
DON'T beam me up, Scotty!
I think that's good decision, Logo ko jo karna hota hai woh karte hai so why not legalise that when it's not creating any harm...
Do you think that we all make an unrefined community?
We're having a healthy debate here. What more proof do you need?
वन्दे मातरम्
This will take a long time in India to be generalized. Here still people talk rubbish if they see a girl and a boy together and now if this is generalized its over.. no nightouts even for boys
Ma'am, we represent just a small, and by small i mean an extremely tiny fraction of the general society. Thats the problem. Yes we are having a healthy debate here, no doubt about that, but things are gonna turn ugly, mark my words. That is the true face of the Indian society. We have ugly scenes even for petty issues like a nightclub...So i don't think that the gay community would be safe no matter what the judgement of the court is.Do you think that we all make an unrefined community?
We're having a healthy debate here. What more proof do you need?
DON'T beam me up, Scotty!
Now this is a good topic for debate.
Personally I have nothing against homosexuallity. But I do think that it is not natural - nature did not desire same genders to have sex.
But note that the Delhi Court ruling applies to Delhi jurisdiction only - not all over India.
*** Never argue with an idiot. ***
All my useful articles and Guides | My DVDs | My Blu-Rays | My Blogs
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I have mixed reactions on this issue. I am not totally in favour of the verdict. Many adverse effects in the society will follow in future.
Last edited by saurav_k; 3rd July 2009 at 02:43 PM.
As said before, its just a verdict, not sure, how many years will take them to stay in the society respectfully. I don't think Indians are ready for it. But in my personal opinion they are no different, I am happy with it. I mean, all humans should be treated equally, one should not be left alone just because he/she have different sex choice than us.
Agreed......!!!!
let the ppl live with their own wishes ......
Dont count wat u lost, cherish wat u ve & plan wat to gain...coz past neva returns but future may return the lost! Think-Decide-Act!!!!
The poll is asking whether "Indian society is ready" and not whether "verdict is correct". In my opinion the answer to former question is "No", to the second "yes".
*** Never argue with an idiot. ***
All my useful articles and Guides | My DVDs | My Blu-Rays | My Blogs
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
exactly the same answer from me also.
I have asked such question because I think
If judiciary system and society think same way then implementation of any new law can be easy otherwise 'practically' such type of law did not get much effect because every law is apparently applied in society.
With Due respect to ES, I have just created a thread Are you happy with the verdict, to know your opinion. Continue your discussion over here. My thread is just for poll to know whether you support or not.
I am a yes on both. I support it and Indian society
will accept it in the long run with some small
pockets of resistance.
-F
and a large no of those small pockets...
dear you are on the net and nobody know you or anything about you.Do you think that we all make an unrefined community?
We're having a healthy debate here. What more proof do you need?
just tell me if we all were around you physically, would you be so comfortable to talk the same ?
:lol: so true...
DON'T beam me up, Scotty!
:d
This whole debate is pointless. in 2012 the whole world is going to end.
All gays, straight everyone will disappear.
-F
aaah a 2012 believer in our midst... then why do a job or do anything at all for that matter... just chill out and enjoy while you can, eh?
DON'T beam me up, Scotty!
ya, but who will feed me and my family for the next two years? ;-)aaah a 2012 believer in our midst... then why do a job or do anything at all for that matter... just chill out and enjoy while you can, eh?
-F
yes, everyone else would disappear.
but that does not apply to you. (ref: Startrek)
well it depends, If I happen to be visiting earth at that time then
I'll join all of you ;-)
-F
i believe you might have saved enough already for this purpose? now is the time to spend it!
DON'T beam me up, Scotty!
no, I spent, lost or gave away all my fortunes...i believe you might have saved enough already for this purpose? now is the time to spend it!
-F
oh well, let's get back on topic.
what do you think the next step will be for gays?
Are they fighting to have gay marriages in India?
-F
lol.. anyways... ya now they will surely want marriages too... i believe there's gonna be a debate of some kind on this issue in the political circle, it was in the news today.
DON'T beam me up, Scotty!
Good point !
You should be a good leader or a good follower ..... Be the best or copy from the guy who is the best .... otherwise u ll be a laggard
aaah a 2012 believer in our midst... then why do a job or do anything at all for that matter... just chill out and enjoy while you can, eh?shouldn't matter to farce, seeing that he's not at earth ATM
What happened to the great Celina, who was very much in support of this... ?
Last edited by newprouser; 4th July 2009 at 10:36 PM. Reason: Automerged Doublepost
They have to fight for the self respect in the society next.
LinkBack URL
About LinkBacks
Reply With Quote